Posted on Leave a comment

Varsity Club

The Varsity Club is by now an institution on the OSU campus. By my count, there are only five bars left, unchanged, that were around in the 20th century (unless you go off-campus a little farther to the likes of Ruby Tuesday), and this is one of them (correct me if I’m wrong, but I think the complete roll call is basically: Out-R-Inn, Bier Stube, The Library, The Little Bar, and this here Varsity Club). The rest have all either swapped identities, suffered complete overhauls, and/or been bulldozed into oblivion before a total rebuild. Yet somehow, despite its prominent location, in the heart of the university and right on Lane Avenue, this was one of the last dominos to fall for us, as far as area bars that we finally got around to visiting

That night of our first ever foray, in the glorious spring of nineteen ninety and eight, ’twere a small mob of us fellows meeting up with some of my coworkers, as we’d already kicked off our night at the Banana Joe’s up on Bethel. The occasion is Carrie’s birthday, and in between the two locales, I manage to scoop up my roommate Alan, after which we then call Snoop and stop by his place on Maynard. I’m expecting Snoop to already be about half in the bag, but this isn’t the case at all. In fact he says he’s not drinking tonight, period…because he feels a bowel movement coming on.

“He’s real funny about that,” Alan tells me in an aside, when I’m snickering about this questionable policy.

“My roommate Matt’s already down there,” Snoop explains to us, meanwhile, as we’re chilling on this front porch, and then descending the wooden steps to Maynard, “he’s been complaining all week, I’m too fat, so then what does he do, he tells me he’s driving to the Varsity Club. I’m like, Matt, it’s only a five minute walk, man! and he’s like, fuck that, I ain’t walkin.

We do just that, however, and it doesn’t take much longer than projected. Once inside, this Varsity Club reveals itself to us as an okay place, though only because we know half the people present. Otherwise it looks like a bit of a snoozefest. Heavy on the wood motif, from the floor to the bar, and Buckeye paraphernalia by the ton, this place reportedly fills up beyond belief – including a basement – during OSU home games, but you wouldn’t guess this at the moment. Apart from a handful of gents standing by the bar in the main room, including Matt and some of their crew, there’s maybe only another dozen people sprinkled throughout, apart from Carrie and company over in the side room. 

“What took you so long?!” Evonne halfway barks at us as we enter, in her somewhat screeching voice. Her personality is such that she often employs this obnoxiousness as a shtick, for comedic effect, or at least to look cool, yet it’s plenty obnoxious anyway. 

“Had to pick my boys up,” I explain with a shrug. 

Carrie is mighty trashed at this early hour, which can diverge in two different directions – neither of them any good. Not for the last time, I feel kind of sorry for David, and wonder how long he’s going to be saddled with this maniac. Which isn’t to say we are able to resist slathering on the b.s. factor, Alan and I, when handing out introductions. 

“This is my roommate,” I tell her, as he takes her right paw and shakes it. 

“Oh really? What does he do?” she returns. 

“He’s a stripper,” I reply, almost reflexively, for it just seems to fly out of my mouth without a conscious thought. 

“You are?” she says, and whips her head around with considerable more interest now. 

“Part time,” he allows. Standing with hands on hips, attempting to look nonplussed as he struggles not to crack up. And yet Alan retains his composure, for Carrie is buying this. 

“Really? Where you dance at?” she asks. 

“Ladies Choice,” I interject, after he stumbles for a fraction of a second too long. 

“Yeah, Ladies Choice,” he concurs, “it’s out on West Broad Street.” 

“You make pretty good money?” 

“Decent,” he shrugs, “about two, three hundred a night maybe.” 

“Think you could dance for me? Since it is my birthday?” 

“I would,” he declines, wrapping up this brilliant piece of ad lib with impressive tact, “but not with your boyfriend sitting there.” 

She doesn’t possess any of these reservations, however. Will in fact reply that David is not her boyfriend, which doesn’t appear to sit well with him. In her fancy dress, she is twirling about the room without a care in the world, broadcasting her cotton white panties for the entire room to see on multiple occasions. Also, in a replay of an identical scene from Banana Joe’s, I’m catching a first-hand glimpse of this competitive streak Jill has warned me about. 

Here, as there, she yanks me out of my chair at one point and begins grinding up against me, vaguely to the beat of this music, a crude effort intended to make me dance, or become turned on by her, or infuriate Jill, or all of the above. “Where’s your girlfriend now!?” she shouts into my ear.  

Like Carrie, I also wouldn’t exactly describe my current situation as a serious one. The difference is I am more than happy if everyone wants to think this. If people are equating Jill and me as a couple already, then it not only means this project is basically in the bag, it also enhances my reputation in a ripple effect with all these other girls. This just seems to be one of the fundamental laws of the universe, with most of them, a constant game of attempted outmaneuvering against their fellow females. 

But I’m not interested in Carrie, and furthermore don’t want to blow it with Jill by tinkering too much with a sure thing. Therefore ditch Carrie to retreat to the modest safety of our table. Here, I find myself stuck in a nice, normal, boring old conversation about music, mostly with Alan, and this middle aged hippie Steve, and this goober named Chad who’s obsessed with Evonne. And this is totally okay with me right now. Chad’s telling us he and his brother had this band called Steel, and then, as a Led Zeppelin tune is blasting overhead, he’s “demonstrating” for us how Bonham’s parts go by air drumming along with them. This time, no amount of poker faced strength can keep us from laughing our heads off. 

We finally manage to detach ourselves from this crew and drift over to the front half, where Snoop and Matt have remained this entire time. The Varsity Club could be more of a later crowd than we initially gave it credit for, with this side of the bar steadily filling still, far closer to capacity than it was when we’d entered. Nothing much changes over here, though, as we soldier on with previously established amusements – like  Alan’s horseshit pickup lines, for example. While I take credit for spinning this wheel into motion, he’s doing a remarkable job at keeping this wildfire spreading rumor mill aflame. 

“Is it true you’re a stripper?” Margie asks, having approached the bar for a drink. 

“Yes, I am,” he tells her. 

“I was reading this article in The Lantern a while back,” she says, “about how a lot of college kids strip to help pay for school.” 

“I read that, too,” Alan tells her, “and as a matter of fact, one of my buddies was featured in that article.” 

By now, Margie is so much putty in his hands. “I’ll bet you make lots of money,” she says. 

“Oh, I do,” he tells her, “and in fact, I’m gonna use some of it right now to buy you a drink.” 

She initially protests, but winds up caving as he buys both of them a beer and a shot. And then lo and behold here is Evonne, back into our midst, followed by Carrie. It’s amazing how sometimes the party will just come to you, on the rare occasion you might come off as the interesting crew for the night…just as it’s amazing how the spin people put on a situation might change in the face of other people’s reactions. 

I wouldn’t claim to have all the answers on these topics my friends and I debate, not by any stretch. But then again, none of us do. It’s more like this constant push and pull, further accented by new information, and the introduction of fresh ideas. Your best bet is to absorb it all while maybe advancing your own opinions, if you think it might influence something, and if the outcome matters. Even then, there’s a continual drift. Damon’s little exhibitionist streak for example has gone from being a slam dunk success to a cringe inducing misfire and at least halfway back again, in the space of a week, because now Evonne is boasting to everyone about seeing my other roommate naked, that she was with Jill during that first brave foray over to our house. My other roommate, whom none of them have even met yet. But of course I can’t resist calling Evonne onto the carpet for this spin job. 

“Hey, didn’t you say you were never coming back to our house again?” I challenge. 

A guilty smile crosses her face and she replies, not exactly convincingly, “I never said that.” 

“That’s not what I heard,” I insist, to which she just laughs. Busted. 

But now Carrie’s slurring, to Alan and me, “I wanna meet Dylan.” 

“Who’s Dylan?” I reply. 

“Or is it Damon?” she asks. We tell her yes, that’s it, add with straight faces that he is a stripper also. “Well, tell him I wanna meet him,” she spits out in her half drunken stupor. This is getting good, and I know he’s going to eat this story up once he hears it. 

Since our appearance, the bar has filled considerably, even though our circle has shrunken somewhat. Matt is the first to call it a nightand then Snoop, who still isn’t drinking, walks home to take a dump. At some point Margie has left, without Alan even as much as getting her digits, although by now he’s already setting his sights on this short, sweet looking random brunette, leaning against the bar. Except, wait a second, she’s not entirely random, not to me – this is Joey, who lasted maybe a month as hostess at my former place of employment, the Damon’s on Olentangy. I’m telling Alan, in case he can’t tell from here, that we all decided she basically had the best ass in the history of mankind, further enhanced in that she often seemed to not be wearing any panties. 

I lead the way over there, to talk to her and hand out introductions yet again. She tells me where she’s working now, though I forget, and asks if I’m still employed at that joke of a restaurant. Alan’s in my other ear asking who this dude is with her, and I admit I don’t know. He swoops in for the kill anyway, requesting to buy her a drink. She shoots him down, albeit with the sweetest, most dimple laden smile imaginable, quite naturally. 

When the lights come up, everyone splinters apart in the same formations we’ve arrived. Our tiny squadron will retrace its steps back to Snoop’s house and sneak around to where I’ve parked. Though Snoop had repeatedly insisted we venture inside his house upon returning, my associate Alan sums up this proposal succinctly in proclaiming, “fuck that.” 

Over the years, we will subsequently make this place an occasional part of our repertoire. Though never quite glimpsing much to get totally gaga over, it can be a fun atmosphere, particularly if the Buckeye spirit has overtaken thee. In more recent times, the Varsity Club’s greatest claim to fame is hosting the empty husk of what used to be known as Hineygate. So if that’s your bag, then by all means check this place out – or if just curious to see a treasured piece of campus history before it too bites the dust.

Varsity Club in Columbus Ohio
Posted on Leave a comment

March 4, 2000

<-March 3

I.


When Melissa’s 21st birthday arrives, bringing with it an invite down to the Alpha Delta Pi sorority house that she calls home, we can scarcely pass this opportunity up. The agreed upon plan is to meet them there at 9, at which point we will all but certainly head out barhopping en masse. Up until this point, in the early evening, Damon’s running errands of some sort around town, while I am chilling out back at my apartment. With me I have my good friend and former coworker Clif, mostly because he’d asked what I was getting into, and I saw no reason not to invite him along.

This will turn out to be a great decision, though also somewhat complicating things in the process. It’s always fascinating to think about certain nights which would have turned out completely differently if you didn’t have this one specific person with you…or the flipside, wondering about outings that went sideways due only to the presence of a single random character. Fortunately this birthday excursion falls into the former category, and will go down as one of my more fondly recalled occasions of this entire era.

Until Damon shows up, Clif and I are playing the Nintendo 64 that I still have lying around, mostly the Mario game – you could call this ironic retro fun, maybe, but this unit is only a few years old, and I don’t have anything else. And when Damon does roll in, he’s smiling as though already knowing what sort of night this will be. Which might not take any outrageous insight to forecast, except that as we climb in my car and motor on down to campus, we’re about a half hour late in arriving.

Also, things have not quite gone as planned with this whole Alpha Delta Pi experience. When we first learned that Melissa was accepted into a sorority, right down here along this murderer’s row of such on 15th, we thought our meal ticket had just been punched to an endless bounty of available young women, ready to throw down at a moment’s notice. However, the first strike emerged almost immediately, which is that she had somehow chosen what has to be the nerdiest sorority OSU offers. For example, they once booted a girl out of here simply for being too slutty (as an amusing sidenote, Melissa brought that chick over to our apartment once, right after this happened, to drink and play cards; when this girl started crying about the treatment she’d received, and quoted how many dudes she slept with – a number in the 30s, if I recall correctly – Lisa, in the sweetest turn I personally have ever witnessed from her, attempted consoling the girl, gently informing her, “that’s not very many! Trust me, that’s not too bad!”).

Point two arrived directly on the heels of the first, which is that most of these girls simply don’t like Damon and me. He and I have subsequently gotten a kick out of dropping by every so often, just to rain on various parades and confirm that, yes, they still hate us. He rates a couple notches higher on the benefit-of-doubt meter simply by having a sister here, but I have never been considered anything less than an out of touch buffoon to them. There are a couple exceptions, most notably Melissa herself, but this has by and large held true, even through an influx of fresh bodies every year.

Parking curbside, we approach their stately, almost southern plantation looking building at 94 E. 15th Avenue. A white brick structure with huge columns supporting it, three stories tall and track lit from the outside like an ancient Roman arena, this could have been the ideal location for countless nights of debauchery, if only these girls weren’t so lame. But who knows, maybe tonight is the night we change all that. At the very least, we figure it is bound to prove interesting.

A couple of girls we don’t recognize are sitting on the front porch, so the three of us continue on past them and inside these massive living quarters. Shrugging out of our coats, we take a moment to appraise our immediate surroundings. A small army of chicks are running around from this room to the next, some gabbing, some still getting ready for the big night.  For once in our lives, we don’t see too many guys crowding the picture, but this is tempered with the knowledge that we’ll never get anywhere with these girls anyway. Indeed, Clif’s presence has changed nothing, as the reception wavers uniformly somewhere between dirty looks to outright indifference. As such, and considering nobody’s ready to leave for the bar yet anyway, we decide to dip back outside, and try our luck with those girls on the spacious front porch.

“You could tell within 5 seconds of walking in that we weren’t hitting it,” I observe, about that living room scene.

“I know!” Damon agrees.

As it turns out, introducing ourselves to these two, that they are ADPi girls as well – but from some Indiana chapter. They’re slightly more pleasant, but only by comparison, would be thought of as rude in virtually any other setting. Soon enough, they stroll away from us as well.

“What the fuck?” Damon wonders, after they disappear from sight.

While it’s possible our reputations precede us to some extent, that theory collapses when considering out of state sisters who are just here for the weekend – there’s simply no way they even know who we are. Therefore I have to assume the same about them as I do these local pledges, that there is a bit of an ageism bias here, whereby we are considered, at a whopping 24 years of age, as a couple of weird “old” guys lurking about their scene. And Clif at 26 or whatever is pretty much ripe for a nursing home.

This has always been my assumption, a major factor in the frosty treatment. Yes there is a bit of a jackass shtick we bring to the table, which they surely aren’t enthralled with, but I would maintain we kept this in check until long after it was established they already didn’t like us. However, my ageism concept also soon suffers a major hit, although in this instance it’s a mostly positive development. With nothing better to do, we three return indoors, where Clif unexpectedly runs into some Vince guy he knows. Who is dating one of these sorority sisters, Tonia.

Tonia, perhaps not so coincidentally, happens to be one of the few exceptions, as far as somebody who doesn’t just tolerate but has actually hit it off with Damon and me. Although come to think of it, I’m not sure if this proves or disproves any of our theories. She’s a short blonde, ever so slightly chubby, with lively blue eyes and, despite wearing braces, a beautiful, captivating smile. A sweet, alluring face that either looks curious or devilish, I can never decide which. Though given to frequent bursts of know-it-all behavior, we find this more amusing than off-putting, possibly because it’s well known that she too is skating on thin ice with many of the sisters in this house. Many find her nauseating, although I suspect jealousy plays a huge part – she’s not just attractive and driven in that whole Tracy Flick-esque sense of the word, but also seems to have ruffled a few feathers by being quoted in Rolling Stone a year or two ago, in some “life on campus” article.

As for Vince, he too seems pretty alright to us. An Asian-American with slicked back black hair, he’s arrived at Columbus via Philadelphia and is reportedly quite a bit older than Tonia, or even us. Someone whispers that he is 30, but if so he doesn’t look it. Whatever the exact figure, he’s somewhere in Clif’s age range, as the two of them once worked together, at one of Clif’s many, many jobs.

So the five of us are hanging out, lounging around the living room furniture as others continue bebopping around the house, still getting ready for tonight. Not everyone is accompanying Melissa’s great 21st birthday brigade, but as a sizeable portion are, which means that many, like us, are waiting for the guest of honor to emerge. And to think that we’d been sweating it, for arriving a half hour late.

“I should have fucking known better,” Damon curses, shaking his head.

In an exceedingly small sub-category, there is exactly one figure stomping around the grounds, whom everyone else likes but we do not. Or rather, it’s not that we don’t like him, more that we feel he is undeniably quite annoying, and can’t believe that nobody else feels this way. Although even so, to his credit, once again we are admittedly talking about someone whose annoying behavior is more hilarious than it is loathsome. This would be Jeff, a tall loudmouth lunkhead we have met once or twice before.

“Come on people, let’s go! Let’s go!” he continues to declare, prowling the premises.

A more detailed picture begins to emerge, once we learn that Jeff and Vince are in fact roommates. For some inexplicable reason, though, the girls all seem to think that Jeff is okay, while most allegedly can’t stand Vince. This apparently has something to do with an incident where he came here drunk and was pissing all over one of the bathrooms. Like I was saying, he fits right in with us.

Bored with this, Damon and I decide to get up and wander around the ground floor ourselves. Though we’ve been upstairs plenty, that area is probably a wisely avoided war zone right now, as the territory occupied by women getting ready is often comparable to parachuting behind enemy lines – and perhaps nowhere more so than here. As we make our rounds, I make various mental notes, about details I’ve possibly missed before.

A word about some of the landscape is in order, then. There are, in essence, two living rooms on the first floor.  One is a more subdued effort, with trophies and built in bookcases, a trifle outdated and musty smelling, the kind of setting where you’d sit around and meet someone’s grandparents when they dropped in from out of state.  The other, which is where we’d congregated, went light on the furniture, but does have a piano in the corner and is more conducive to large crowds of people standing around.  During one previous visit, Damon and I got on this juvenile kick of hiding those trophies in various places around the house. Although at a glance it appears they have all been discovered and returned.

“Come on people, let’s go!  Let’s get a move on!” Jeff is hollering, it never lets up. Even in casual conversation, he has but a single, ear punishing volume, or so I thought until he began this even louder shouting routine just now. Still, I really can’t fault the guy. At least he’s actively trying to get everyone rounded up and the hell out of this house.

Though the minutes continue to pass and we now find ourselves hanging out in the hotel restaurant sized kitchen, leaning against an island in the middle, my enthusiasm hasn’t wavered any. I’ve been pumped all evening, possessed by this feeling from the outset that something great would happen tonight. And it does, which is so often the case when these rare, static electricity hunches overtake me. Although this does lead me to wonder, if it’s a true premonition or whatever, that a terrific turn of events was soon arriving, or rather if thinking this is what causes such to happen.

I tend to lean toward the latter, but the caveat is that it has to be something you truly believe, not just some weak “thinking positive” mindset you’re attempting to paste onto your thoughts. At this moment in time, however, absent any definitive evidence, all we have is our usual idle chitchat, in this still fairly exotic setting, while we continue to wait.

“You know what would be funny,” I’m telling Damon, as we brainstorm ways to continue irking these girls, during future visits, “is if we brought in some hookers.”

He laughs heartily at this notion, and it is admittedly a hilarious one even to me. If they hate us now, bringing some ladies of the night with us next time, preferably some really scuzzy, older and grizzled types, at least for the purposes of this theoretical thought exercise, now that would really rattle some cages. Maybe two or three apiece, draped all over us, as we kick back and sip rotgut wine in their living room or something.

At long last, however, the crowd begins thinning out. It had long ago been decided that our first destination will be Quarters, formerly known as The Jailhouse, up on Lane Avenue. Some are walking the half dozen or so blocks north up High Street, while still others are committed to driving there. In the latter camp, Vince and Tonia are kind enough to approach us, and offer to give Damon, Clif, and me a lift. We thank them and politely decline, however, as the three of us are still waiting on Melissa to emerge. Clear up until there’s almost no one left in the house, and Damon asks one of the few remaining sisters what’s taking her so long. This is when we learn that Melissa had already left without us, some fifteen minutes ago.

II.


The three of us don’t get very far, however, traipsing up High, before encountering members of our party. Specifically, we spot Melissa and three of the other girls, hanging out in front of the iconic campus McDonald’s, which has been here since at least the 1980s. “Speh some change?” Damon asks, in a raspy voice, as we approach them. The ladies all laugh at his joke, and soon enough fall in beside us as we continue walking toward the bar.

At Lane Avenue, Clif and I alone manage to cross the street while everyone else gets hung up at the light. Looking back, I can see that loudmouth Jeff, despite his endless clarions to get the troops moving, must have actually left the house after almost everyone, or else gotten sidetracked – he has just fallen in with the rest of our group, behind us. So as Clif and I are just talking our sweet time approaching Quarters, allowing the others to catch up, we happen to glance up at this gyro place next door, spot Vince and Tonia seated at a table in there, having just ordered a late dinner. Then decide on this whim to pop in there and join them. Part of the attraction is that, even from here, the food smells too good to resist.

Although all I wind up ordering is a cheeseburger and a Mountain Dew. Vince and Tonia haven’t gotten their food yet, so it isn’t as though we’re holding them up any. Clif sits chatting, mostly with his old buddy Vince, who stills seems mostly chill and kind of funny, even. And then from out of nowhere, we are suddenly joined by Jeff. He too spotted this table in the window, and could not resist its fragrant allure.

Not that I’m paying much attention to him. Rather, as on previous encounters, I’m feeling like this Tonia actually digs me somewhat, and that I just might be able to pull this off if playing my best game. Assuming the very unfortunate circumstance of her someday breaking up with this Vince character, of course, of course. But at the very least, I think I’m developing a decent idea of what makes her tick. She’s one of these people who has to command everyone’s attention, and therefore the best strategy is to ignore her. To that end I grab a USA Today and sit there reading it intently, while everyone else converses – which openly and unmistakeably intrigues her as much as it drives her nuts. Maybe this doesn’t happen often, but it’s always satisfying when it does, to have this notion about what would work with somebody, and to see that panning out.

But there’s still much work to be done, if indeed I’m not entirely delusional to begin with. And I’m doing myself no favors with a clumsy streak, i.e. spilling my Mountain Dew all over the place. Lacking enough napkins at the table, I grab Jeff’s paper bag in desperation, which his food just arrived in, and use that to soak up the last of it – though he sits gasping, he doesn’t utter a word of protest. The USA Today might have been a more obvious choice, but I couldn’t resist this latest piece of jackass shtick, and everyone else saves Jeff finds this hilarious.

What can I say, I am kind of feeling “on” with the comedy tonight, and can tell that Damon is in the same zone. After finally arriving next door at the bar, I reconvene with him so that he can brief me on any relevant developments. While he would admittedly not quibble with just about any girl in the entire entourage, he’s set his sights on this Katy chick, with whom he has already developed a rapport with in their short time here.

“Where’s Katy? Where’s Katy?” he keeps asking, as we sit at the bar itself for quite some time, determined not to lose track of her.

I’m also onhand as he dispenses an early lesson to Melissa, advising her that at some point, she is going to have to start turning down the shots, or else this is going to be a very short night for her. Quite naturally, however, she listens to none of this, and is subsequently one of the first people to throw in the towel on her own birthday extravaganza, thoroughly blasted and puking in calling it a night. She does, however, throw her arms around me, and drunkenly declare that she is so happy that I made it. “I told Damon, he’s gotta come!” she slurs.

But we’ve got other concerns, and I don’t even notice the specific moment of her exit. Among the peculiarities grabbing our attention is that this place is dead, despite it being a Saturday night, a far cry from the glory years of The Jailhouse or even the early days of this Quarters enterprise. In fact, it’s entirely possible that our entourage represents the only patrons this bar has right now. A group which clocks in at, as far as we can determine, just us five guys, surrounded by about 30 sorority chicks. Some of this is understandable – unlike bars most everywhere else in the known universe, campus establishments do most of their business during the week, with Thursday being the peak night; come Friday, and especially Saturday or Sunday, half the kids have driven home to be with their family, long distance boyfriends/girlfriends, and so forth. Still, a prime weekend night would have never been quite this lethargic, even just a year or two ago. Not that we are complaining the least bit about this phenomenal ratio, at what amounts to a private bash.

“This makes up for all the sausage parties I’ve been to over the years,” I tell Vince, over top of some frantic hip-hop beat. With not a single soul on the dance floor, the music their house DJ is pumping out bounces off the walls like molecules fired from an atom splitter.

“Oh, absolutely,” he agrees, sizing up the field.

Much of the decor seems the same as those Jailhouse days, so I’m not sure about the reasoning behind the name change. Quarters has floor to ceiling poles, spaced about two or three inches apart, lining the dance room like an actual jail cell.  Dark lighting aplenty, broken up only by the flashing colored pin spots sweeping said dance floor, unless you counted the garish neon signs mounted behind the bar, beckoning you forward toward your favorite intoxicant.   And, of course, a requisite pair of pool tables, tucked safely downstairs, away from all the commotion.

At some point, Clif and I decide to drift downstairs and avail ourselves of this last refuge. And this basement is also exactly as I remember: exceedingly musty, wooden planks on the walls bowed ridiculously inward, the concrete floor uneven and cracked. Yet none of that really matters, so long as there’s enough room to shoot.

Racking and breaking, despite announcing this scene change to nobody, we only get to a place where one of us has sunk two balls before Jeff comes loping down here after us. Vince and Tonia are right behind him, an inexplicable development – albeit one cracking me up as I picture the scene upstairs. Unless you count the help, Damon now has about….twenty-nine sorority chicks, all to himself. Maybe twenty-eight, depending upon whether Melissa is still here or not. And maybe this was a stupid idea to begin with, venturing down here, but I’ve never had a ton of success drooling over chicks, I do far better just hanging back and acting normal, as though not even noticing they’re here. Whomever I cross paths and bump elbows with, it’s great, it just feels natural, and I can make things happen then. Besides, apart from the birthday girl herself, I would still maintain that my most realistic option is down here in the basement right now anyway. And indeed, despite her boyfriend’s presence, she certainly appears to be laying it on extra thick in getting me to pay attention to her.

Nonetheless, Jeff remains an unavoidable sideshow, one it is physically impossible to ignore. As soon as he arrives down here, having already boasted of his billiards prowess at various points tonight, he feels the need to prove it.

“Alright, me and her,” he announces, pointing at Tonia, “against you guys, and I’ll give you those two balls as a handicap.”

Glancing at one another, Clif and I just shrug before casually agreeing to his terms. We have not the first clue what mayhem lies off in the distance, and that this will eventually wind up as but merely the second (and a distant second at that) most memorable table game of the night. As for Tonia, she is only sheepishly, reluctantly drawn into Jeff’s brash orbit, and he very nearly pulls this off. What happens is that the game gets down to where there’s just an 8 ball on the table, and Jeff scratches when shooting it. Awesome. Totally fucking awesome.

Back upstairs, regrouping with Damon, we assess the current situation. As the only male up here for quite some time (unless counting the lone guy bartending, flanked by a pair of women back there, or the isolated DJ) he’s been enjoying quite the field day.  Cheerfully hopping from one table to the next, he’s really come alive since we left him. Discussing matters, it occurs to us that as among the few who are over 21 years of age – a field further weakened with Vince being spoken for and neither Jeff nor Clif demonstrably doing much to pull in any ladies themselves – we should be playing this angle up to our full advantage. He and I are at least attempting to work the field, although his methods are typically a lot more over the top or at least forthright than mine. And on this note, he has a flash of insight leading to one of his most brilliant gambits ever: we will buy rounds for all the ladies here, yes – but the rounds in question will actually be nothing more than tray after tray full of Pepsis.

And this strategy works like a charm, ridiculous or not. It’s a safe bet that most if not all of these girls have acquired multiple drinks already, by whatever means, and are too drunk to tell the difference. Now they like us just fine, sure. Who knows, maybe this was just the icebreaker for the ages that we needed, and will win them over forevermore.

There’s no reason to think beyond the present tense, however. By now, Clif has had the good sense to join us, for this hilarious and borderline surreal piece of theater. Damon’s big idea is that if he springs for a tray full of Pepsis, dispensed into normal looking cocktail glasses, and then casually walks over to some random table with them, that the girls will come flocking, assuming that these are shots. Which is in fact exactly what happens. From this distance, Clif and I are nearly pissing ourselves with laughter – right before we launch into action with trays of our own. And the bartenders quite naturally don’t give a shit, are possibly even relieved that these underage students are going gaga for soft drinks, and continue dispensing refills for free beyond this point.

This glorious turn evolves into two of us hanging at the table while a third guy retrieves the next tray, taking turns on rotation. Meanwhile, these girls have fleshed out the remaining chairs around it, with still others hanging on us, throwing their arms around our shoulders like long lost best friends, asking if they can please have another one of these “shots.” They are at one point as much as three deep, swarming in a circle around these tables, clamoring for another of these delicious concoctions.

Jeff is nowhere to be seen while this is going on, which is really just as well, and he may have already left. Meanwhile Vince and Tonia are among the handful trifling with the dance floor at this point. And once this shot onslaught runs its course, a handful more fall into formation out there, as Clif and I stand just off to the side, surveying the action. Tonia keeps bending over and shaking her ass mere inches from my crotch, yet though I continually glance over at Vince to gauge his reaction, he appears oblivious to her shenanigans. She soon grows bored, however, either due to the lack of drama or the attention paid to her, and with a phone number shouted in my ear before they disembark, these two are also gone.

And then it’s hard to say what happened. So much for that notion of a permanent icebreaker, obviously. Because one moment Damon, Clif and I are cracking up and high fiving over beers at the bar, the next it seems we turn around and the entire OSU chapter of Alpha Delta Pi is gone. The OSU one, yes. Because by whatever improbable turn of events, the three of us find ourselves in the company of no one else but…four girls from that Indiana chapter. These chicks are in the same boat as we, for everyone else they were with took off without them. And it’s right here that the night takes its next dramatic turn.

“I know this party on Norwich we can hit,” the skinny, somewhat whiny one named Darcy tells us.

III.


“Don’t let her out of your sight,” Damon whispers to me, jabbing a finger in Darcy’s direction. He has to dip into the restroom before we depart, and, quite correctly, recognizes this as the best opportunity we’ve had all night, likely in many a night.

Not that we have anything to worry about. These ladies cotton to us alright, and it certainly doesn’t hurt that they are lost without our navigation. Darcy has a street name, sure, though I get the impression she has no idea where it’s actually located. Assuredly, they could have found their way back to ADPi without us, but this big city is mostly foreign and possibly somewhat dangerous to them, they would rather not brave it alone. Having a few harmless dorks like us around is a compromise they can live with.

The seven of us weave our way a few blocks northeast, and almost immediately stumble upon a throbbing scene at this house on Norwich. No one bothers checking the address, and in fact might not even possess such. Darcy and the one quite large girl – we never learn her name – are both convinced that this has to be it, and so we approach the place.

Not that getting inside the house will prove to be very easy, as by estimation there have to be a thousand kids, easy, crammed onto and within this property. This is by far the biggest party I have ever seen contained at somebody’s residence. But biggest doesn’t necessarily mean best, and it truly is a physical challenge to wade our way through this crowd. If it were just us three guys, we probably wouldn’t even bother, unless in a seriously determined mood. The girls wish to be here, however, and as we ask random passerby about a keg, the consensus is that there’s one buried deep within the recesses of the back yard.

Front yard, front porch, back yard, back porch, the living room and kitchen and all the other rooms in between, we navigate this jam packed maze to that potential treasure chest awaiting at the end. During this process, somehow the strawberry blonde, Chrissy, and I become separated from everyone else. Black lights are flickering in the sticky hot swamp of a living room, and for whatever reason, though normally not even a move that would ever occur to me, I take her hand, lead her through these bodies, with the rap music so loud in our ears it is almost attacking us as a physical presence.

It’s hard to explain, but though I hadn’t been paying her any more attention than the others up until that moment, from that point forward, we just click. I’m sure she appreciates my little chivalrous turn, guiding her through the land and all, and yet it isn’t until we come up for air on the backside of this house that we can really even talk. Chrissy instantly reminds me of a Natasha Lyonne with somewhat reddish but mostly blonde, curly hair. Otherwise quite similar in appearance and personality, or so it seems to me, down to the soft though plenty curvaceous figure, the wide eyed yet mishievous countenance, the husky voice and sarcasm and bluntness. She’s quite attractive, yes, and I would most certainly love to hook up with her. And while she doesn’t spell out any particular interest in me, I get the impression this interest is just as swiftly reciprocated.

When we had made it as far as the kitchen, where some conventional lighting blessedly awaited us, I had risked a look behind us, and could glimpse Clif making his way, with Damon and the objectively hottest of the four Indiana girls, Amanda, a bit further beyond. And no clue about the other two whatsoever, although they did seem the ones most likely to know a familiar face here. Now, with Chrissy and I having stopped for a moment, these other three catch up to us, and I take a moment to fully appraise Amanda’s appearance. In much the same manner as I had, Damon, the lucky bastard, seems to have somehow connected with his randomly appointed sidekick in identical fashion, in the time it took to cross the house. Amanda’s skinny and has a sweet, innocent look to her, sandy brown shoulder length hair, and what Damon and Clif and I, in whatever private conferences we are able to manage, has to be about the tightest ass we have even seen.

But I’m not complaining in the slightest. Chrissy is 100% my type, which makes tonight’s absurd chain reaction of unlikely occurrences all the stranger. As a mostly reunited mass, though, we have no choice except to confront and resume the purported end goal of this quest. The line is considerably intidimating, however, and as we continue moving in the vague direction of where we were told the keg would be, fifteen, twenty, maybe thirty minutes might pass – time stands still out here, which only servces to make the passing minutes impossible to gauge. A little red bucket and a Salvation Army bell would come in handy right now. Although, who are we kidding, it would take nothing short of an ambulance siren to part these masses right now, and even that might not work.

“I’m gonna take a piss,” Clif eventually declares, tapping out of this slow shuffle and disappearing once more into its dark inner recesses.

But wait, what is this? Land ho! After untold minutes crossing this vast sea, a keg at last appears before us, the confirmation that we have indeed stood in a line all this time and not simply swayed around the back yard for no reason. Only for the four of us to reach it, and discover…there are no cups. We have been to who knows how many collective keg parties, and it never occurred to any of us that this might be a concern.

What now? A thousand impatient nineteen year olds burn holes in the back of our heads, we’ve got to think fast. But really, there’s only one thing we can do. “Fuck this,” we say, with slight variations. I take Chrissy’s hand once more, steering her away from here, and spotting my maneuver, Damon does the same thing in grabbing Amanda’s.

Darcy and the other one have not been spotted anywhere for quite some time, in fact none of us are certain they even made it as far as the house. Plus, we have no idea what became of Clif. But then in retracing our steps, we find the other two girls waiting basically right where we left them, on the sidewalk, as though knowing things would turn out exactly like this. Except they are much more impatient now, and Darcy’s whining even more than before.

I get it, though. The air has grown downright chilly, dropping farther with every minute, and none of them have coats. In the meantime, we’ve got to continue standing here under the flimsy assumption that my friend will magically reappear. As we continue to stand around and shiver here, I can feel each tick of the second hand on my watch, knowing full well that our chances of sticking with these girls are exponentially decreasing with each.

“What do we do?” a distraught Damon whispers to me, and we are always on such a similar wavelength that it’s wordlessly communicated exactly what he means, also that I get it.

Pressure compounding, it closes in and begins to wrap around us like a fog. The girls are talking about partying some more, but are clearly on the brink of saying goodnight if we intend to keep standing here. But then, by some miracle, at what is near to the last possible minute, here comes Clif skidding out of the crowd and onto the sidewalk.

Not that we are out of the woods just yet. Continuing back to High Street and then south upon it, Darcy won’t stop complaining – it’s too cold, it’s too late, they’ve got such a long drive back to Indiana at the conclusion of this weekend. Now that Clif has returned, she has instead turned into the largest threat, with the potential for wrecking whatever potential this night still holds. Even the 4-3 disparity in theoretical pairings isn’t quite the black cloud that her presence is.

And yet they continue to hang with us, in fact it is agreed we’ll get some carry out beer and then figure out where to drink it. Whatever their reservations, Clif’s apartment is one option being tossed around, for he at least keeps his pad tidy and lives in a nice part of town. Whereas I am worried that any potential female guests would take one look at my ghetto apartment and turn right back around.

Our first thought is to acquire beverages at the UDF on the corner of Frambes. We suddenly realize it’s past 1am, however, which means that this option is out, and the only other is to pay through the nose for to-go brewskies from some bar. The Out-R-Inn is conveniently located right behind here, and once our eyes settle upon it, we instantly recognize that here lies the path forward. It’s decided that Damon and I will stroll over there to purchase the required essentials, while these underage girls wait behind. And Clif. Chrissy is wearing my coat by now, and we don’t really expect them to bail on us, but leaving him in their mix as “collateral” seems like a good idea all the same.

After we return with a case of Natty Lite apiece, our miniature mob continues moving down High. At this juncture Darcy’s complaints have now morphed into bitching about all their fellow traveling sisters that ditched them, and wondering what became of those girls. Finally arriving back at the sorority house, however, we encounter a handful of local ones who are still awake, and tell us about some frat party further down 15th that they intend to hit. Once again we are somewhat hanging back and just taking cues from our ladies, and when it seems obvious that they really want to check this out, we stash the beer in my car and walk up to the street to that fraternity.

As far as I can recall, this is my first ever visit to a frat house. In a truly momentous night chock full of memorable revelations and developments, our time here will rank right up there near the top of the list. I feel as though we have passively hated upon frat boys our entire lives without really taking the time to know any, or understand their people’s culture. This isn’t going to turn into a full fledged defense of the boneheaded bro lifestyle or anything, but…I think there’s more to the story here than maybe we ever realized. Also that this particular story is maybe filed disconcertingly very close on the bookshelf to ours. Just on a higher shelf.

But as we knock on the front door of this massive though faceless manor, one I would struggle to pick out in a photo lineup from all the others on this row, some out of the loop seeming frat brother answers. He’s either just gotten home or just awakened from a nap. The girls are all in front of the pack – us three guys stick to the back – and one of them asks about a party.

“Uh….yeah….but I’m not sure if it’s started yet, we weren’t going to let people in until 2:30.”

“Can we come in now?”

“Hold on, let me check,” he says and shuts the door.  Damon and I exchange amused grins and raised eyebrows – here we were, always trying to con girls into coming to our place, whereas these cats wouldn’t even let them in unless the timing was right.  Slick, very slick.  The kind of slick that throws parties which begin at 2:30 in the morning.

He comes back moments later and, having just learned there were already about thirty people in his basement – imagine that – the dude says okay, sure, we can come on in. Even so, it immediately becomes apparent to us that while all these females are quite welcome, us men are bound for a much frostier reception. This is totally our initial impression, that it’s cool we brought some women and everything, but don’t expect cordiality, and in fact it may be best, hint hint, if we just take a hike.

At least up until the night’s next strange twist rears it’s head. I’ve been marveling for years at just how many people Clif knows, seemingly everywhere I go with him. And that scenario has already occurred once, much earlier tonight, when he unexpectedly crossed paths with Vince. Only to repeat yet again at this of all places – some Cory guy, who is a fraternity brother residing in this household, used to work with him. He sees Clif and is borderline giddy, shouting his name with enthusiasm. And from this moment forward, we are suddenly golden.

I don’t harbor any ill feelings about the initial cold shoulder. In fairness, we typically act pretty much the same when unfamiliar dudes crash our parties. Now that we are brought into the fold – if not exactly anywhere near their equals – I can see that we’ve also been 100% wrong about this entire scene. Much like most of the popular kids in high school turned out to be, I can see that by and large…these dudes are basically doing the same shit as us, running the same kinds of games with the same attitudes. They’re just doing it at a much higher level.

I still don’t believe that it was any form of bitterness, jealousy about how successful these characters have been with this crap; I think it’s more this blind assumption that this was a very cheesy, shallow existence, and that these fratholes were just some extremely lucky dumbasses. A perception aided in large part by endless depictions of such in movies and TV shows, sure. But let’s get real, here. They are members of a prominent organization smack dab in the heart of this internationally renowned juggernaut of a university. A lot of these guys have brighter futures than we, a lot of them are probably really smart.

And if they’re not smart, they’re at least clever. Again, to hate them is ridiculous, because an awful lot of this smacks of our stunts – if only we were a little bit better at them. This was obvious before we even set foot inside here, like that junk about not allowing a bunch of hot women into their house before 2:30am. University policy is also giving them a huge leg up, too, for example in permitting alcohol inside fraternities, yet outlawing it within sororities. In other words a policy all but shepherding the ladies to their doorstep.

I’m much more interested in the similarities I detect, however. For specific examples, as we’re now gathered in the quote unquote basement – which is just an exquisitely furbished rec room – there’s this table game nearby, charred around the edges. An incongruous sight, even here, and I just know there’s a story here, one that I must ask Cory about.

“Hey, why does that foosball table have burn marks all around the edges?” I inquire, after we’ve each grabbed a cold Miller Light from this ice filled trough behind their bar.

He turns his head to glance over at it before calmly explaining, “oh, we stole that from Papa Joe’s as it was burning down.”

Whoa. If true, and nothing about his casual delivery makes me doubt this in the least, then this is an amazing little piece of local history that not a whole lot of people can possibly know about. Papa Joe’s was a campus instution, a pizza shop on High that went up in flames a few years ago, taking the Waterbeds N’ Stuff next door with it. Suddenly, I know that I absolutely must play on that table tonight. But first, other curiosities await, like the life-sized traffic light propped up in one corner – I never realized how large these things truly are, for they do not appear as such when dangling above your car in an intersection. Yet I never quite get around to asking about its origin, because Cory can’t resist telling me how they acquired this fully functional Pepsi machine.

“We stole that from the student union hall,” he tells me, chortling as he casts his mind backwards to this sequence of events, “it was funny, we told the kids working there that we’d come to fix it, but we had to take it with us.”

“No way,” I marvel, grinning in admiration at their demented brilliance.

“Yep,” he nods, “they even helped us load it onto our truck. And what was funny was we called the guys at Pepsi a few days later and told them we lost our key to the machine, so they sent a guy out here to give us a new one and we got, like, sixty dollars’ worth of change out of it.”

Clif is overhearing this too, of course, and we’re both laughing so hard that our stomachs threaten to split open. Only when we at last compose ourselves are we able to contemplate this matter of the legendary foosball table. With Damon off wandering around, to fully inspect the landscape, he and I are left to try out this piece of Papa Joe’s memorabilia, enhanced by this unexpected bonus of Chrissy and Amanda cheering us on, courtside.

Following a couple games of this, they leave to play Damon and someone else over at the pool table. This is when a couple of the preppier looking residents walk up, to challenge us to an exceedingly high stakes foosball game. High Stakes: what this means is that, according to them, there’s a house rule involving something called a bun run. If either side manages a 10-0 shutout, then the losing team must run a lap around the exterior of this massive house. With a fully naked bottom half.

Well, we can say that it’s only totally obvious what happened in retrospect. Sure. That’s why Clif and I agreed to this madness. But it must be said that they surely play these same rules against one another all the time, I don’t sense that this was invented out of thin air just for us. Only problem is, we are quite bad at this game, when compared to them. And even then, if we really wanted to press the point for a ready escape hatch, then an opportunity presents itself with the score 7-0 in their favor. One of these guys knocks the ball into his own goal, which seemingly lets us off the hook.

“Doesn’t count,” he says, however, as they drop the ball back into play. And so we play on without any protest, with two possible opposing reasons for doing so – either that we are feeling so confident in our ability to score one goal, or else we are feeling so unconfident in our ability to win this argument, in their house. I know for me, it’s a little of both. I do enjoy a good challenge, yes. But also recognize that they are hellbent on making us look like fools, and the best thing we can do is take our medicine like men. I’m not going to be found whimpering, and begging them not to humiliate me. We’ll just go along with this, and whatever.

Ten minutes later, Clif and I are in their foyer, taking off everything from the waist down. This is admittedly a little less mortifying than it otherwise might be, when considering that this is actually far from the first time that I have run around outside naked. “You guys can keep your shoes,” they tell us, which does help, considering this Ohio weather isn’t exactly tropical at 3am in the beginning of March.

It also serves to hasten our pace considerably, as we dash out the circumference of their sizeable estate. I take off first across their front yard, figuring this would be preferable to staring at Clif’s skinny black ass in front of me. At all the doors and windows, the guys huddle around and snicker, check our progress, while the chicks generally laugh outright and point. Panting, I arrive back at the front door only moments before Clif, where I’m relieved to discover what is my actual worst and only true fear – that they would lock us out to further perpetuate the prank – is fortunately unfounded.

We grab our clothes and quickly dress, and if there’s a silver lining to this, it’s that no one in our little party is even aware that this went down. Chrissy and Amanda are still playing pool with Damon, while Darcy and the other girl left shortly after we arrived here. Better yet, when I finally encounter Damon again, it turns that they’ve just finished their games and he’s been looking for me. While Clif and I were outside, some serious scheming had transpired in our absence, and Damon has me follow him into the nearest restroom for a complete lowdown.

“That Chrissy says to me, I really like your friend Jason, how hard do you think it will be for me to hook up with him?” Damon laughs, “I didn’t want to tell her, well, basically, if you drop your pants…”

“Yeah,” I chuckle. But then he continues, explaining that Chrissy had just pressed onward, bluntly stating the deal in what I can so vividly picture, without even being present, her very Natasha Lyonne-esque manner as she blurted this out.

“So she tells me, I’ll hook you up with Amanda if you hook me up with Jason,” Damon explains, chuckles again as he adds, “sounded good enough to me! Only thing is, she asked me how we were going to get rid of that Clif guy.”

IV.


On the surface our new blueprint seems somewhat sinister, even though technically nothing has changed at all. The plan always was for me to run Clif home after this, and that’s exactly what we intend to do now. It’s just that there’s the added wrinkle of these women at the end of this odyssey, for Damon and me, so long as we don’t blow it.

When he asks me what I think we should do, I rub my chin for a few ponderous seconds before saying, “I could drive him home, say I was going home myself but that you were gonna stick around here and party with the girls some more. Then you could ride with them in their car, meet me at my house.”

“That should work,” he nods in agreement, as we exit the restroom to set these wheels in motion.

I feel bad for lying to Clif, but at the same time, can’t think of any way to spin the truth that would be less harsh. Hey dude, those chicks wanna hook up with us, but they said you gotta go. Would that be somehow better? And as I’ve stated, his outcome would wind up the same no matter how we played this. I’m sure there are some really hardcore types out there who would say, no man! You draw the line in the sand and tell those chicks, bro! It’s one for all and we stick together as a team! But that’s just silly. It’s now almost 4am and he would be wanting a ride home soon anyway.

Even so, it does bother me, as I’m convinced that this wouldn’t have panned out in quite the same manner if he hadn’t gotten us accepted into that frat party. Maybe things unfold in a basically similar manner, particularly as Chrissy and I were already bonding at the first house, who knows. I think we probably do end up in bed together either way, but not this immediately, and the part about Damon and Amanda doesn’t happen at all. So this is kind of like you’ve made it to the World Series, but then the day before it starts, you release one of the key guys who got you there.

As we climb into my car, I don’t get the impression he suspects anything. More just wistfulness, as though wishing he could remain behind with Damon to party some more as well. Although he does ask me, when we are nearing his apartment off of Henderson, if I think we will meet up again with Chrissy and Amanda down the road, if Damon or I had managed to get their digits and so on. Here I have to conjure up on the spot another diplomatic but technically true response, in this case muttering something about, uh, yeah, I’m pretty sure we will make something happen with those girls.

Flying across town back to my apartment, I’m not sure it’s a good sign at all to see that they haven’t arrived yet. Damon does after all have a key here, and for that matter I have an actual roommate, Big Paul, who may or may not be present – as has been increasingly the case, I’m not exactly sure where he is at the moment. He could be locked in his room or out still carousing on the town. Whatever the case, he missed one hell of a night with us – even though once again, I am grateful he skipped this one, as that too might have thrown off the dynamic just enough.

But then I’ve no sooner popped all of these Natty Lites into the fridge, when this trio magically materializes. And in no time we’ve got beers open, the living room disco ball spinning for good effect, and are playing a card game at the coffee table, Asshole, which I’ve not quite gotten into, though these college age females sure do love it.

For whatever reason, inspired by a show we’d seen awhile back, Damon and I get on this kick reciting the lyrics to Neil Young’s Tonight’s the Night, in particular anything to do with the word shaky. That was his keyword of the night and we are destined to repeat it. So yeah, extreme weirdness, but these girls aren’t bothered by our peculiarities in the least. Damon for example cannot remember Amanda’s name for the life of him, but as she keeps talking about an upcoming trip to Florida, he continues to call her Florida instead. But I think she mostly digs that. And you know, weirdos or not, I believe we have absolved ourselves in spectacular fashion tonight – maybe some of those frat guys are banging hotter chicks tonight, but these two look pretty damn good. We went into the belly of the beast and still emerged to bring them home with us.

Not that we’ve sealed the deal just yet, mind you. For now we must at least feign some passing interest in this card game, even if doing so requires blurting out nonsensical song lyrics. A typical exchange therefore passes with a sequence very close to this.

Shaky shaky shaky shaky, I might be singing, to pass the time, in a facsimile of Neil’s high pitched warble.

Bruce Berry…Bruce Berry, Damon would add.

“It’s your turn,” one of the girls tells one of us.

Shaky shaky shaky

“Go. I’m the president, I make the rules here.”

Bruce…Bruce…Bruce…

“Okay, my new rule is, there’s no cussing.”

Shaky shaky Bruce Bruce

Bruce Berry…Bruce Berry

“Alright,” Amanda finally demands, after so much of this, “who is this Bruce Berry, anyway?”

“Bruce Berry was a real hard worker,” I explain.

“Yeah, he used to load an Econoline van,” Damon adds.

These two are the picture of puzzlement, attempting to find any two pieces whatsoever to snap together about what we’ve just said. This reminds me of a very similar conversation, actually, during the Y2K New Year’s, over at Alan’s cousin’s place. One of the girls we were playing cards with there, in response to mine and Alan’s thoroughly bizarre, music related “conversation,” had sighed and said, I can never figure out what guys are talking about. Regarding this moment tonight, Damon will later tell me, “you know what it is, man, is we move so fast, bouncing from topic to topic, I don’t think these girls can follow what we’re saying.”

Maybe, but I don’t think that always applies, and certainly not in this instance. My take is that in situations like these, when you are attempting to get with a girl for the first time, progress must move in a spiral motion if you hope to get anywhere. Now that we’ve gotten them to the house, with basically just one last hurdle remaining, we have to spend x amount of time focusing on anything else in the universe except sex. Or at least put up a solid front of pretending to. And this card game, even the Bruce Berry nonsense, is as good as anything else.

I fully expect to take Chrissy upstairs with me tonight. It feels impossible to derail that train at this point. Assessing Damon’s chances is a little trickier – Amanda seems to like him alright, yet Chrissy had made it sound as though she would have to do some convincing to sway her friend. And Amanda does look killer, slender and tan, wearing these tight black pants that perfectly frame her magnificent behind. Chrissy is a really attractive girl, too, near the top range of my all-time list…but man, if Damon manages to pry the panties off this Amanda, then I will really be impressed.

Everything is moving in right direction, though. After the card game has either worn down or the girls have grown tired of our singing, Chrissy asks me, “hey, do you have a TV in your room?”

“Yes ma’am,” I reply.

“Let’s go upstairs and…watch some TV,” she suggests.

Who am I to object? The two of us begin making this move, as Damon pulls out the couch bed for himself and Amanda to climb into. Upstairs, though flicking on the television, Chrissy and I otherwise immediately abandon this pretense and begin making out, then transfer this action to the bed. Less than six hours after meeting this girl from IU, I begin yanking off her clothes, and she mine, with those other two downstairs hopefully making similar introductions to one another.

Up here, our top halves are fully naked now. She has some killer breasts, which I explore in detail, then begin kissing her belly. Only when I start to unbutton these beige colored jeans she’s wearing does Chrissy throw up the first stop sign of the night. “Let’s…chill out with that,” she tells me.

“You don’t want to take this any further?” I ask.

“Not today,” she says.

But that’s cool. This is only a temporary roadblock. And right around this time, I realize, amusingly enough, that birds are chirping outside my window. Which is when I glance over and discover that it’s daylight outside now, too. And here I have to be to work at 9 o’clock this morning. We soon fall asleep, and I grab a couple hours of shuteye before making it over there.

Postscript:

When I have a chance to compare notes with Damon, after racing home from work, he reveals that he wasn’t able to nail Amanda, that they just kissed briefly before she told him she was really tired and went to sleep. “I kind of expected that, though,” he admits, “I was telling myself, man, he’s gonna go up there and bang his chick, but I’ll be lucky just to make out with mine a little bit.” I confess to him that I did not in fact have sex with Chrissy yet, but that this was obviously just a formality, her taking a pointed stance to slow things down a smidgen.

And we manage to keep this going for awhile, too, with both girls, to varying degrees. Chrissy writes me a sweet note before leaving town, as we all exchange email addresses and phone numbers. Amusingly enough, though, Chrissy first emails Damon, explaining that she was too nervous to pop this question to me herself, but asking him if he would ask me if I might be willing to come to Indiana to see her – this sets my mind spinning, actually, with the possibilities involved in becoming so distant that girls are contacting my friends instead and asking them to get ahold of me on their behalf; my game does admittedly tick up another level once I begin applying some of those concepts. Hilarious, to be sure. There is one weekend later on, though, where the four of us have plans to meet at this hotel halfway in between our two distant cities, before Amanda gets cold feet and taps out at the last minute. After this, it’s never quite the same. We still stay in somewhat frequent contact with them, though, until things begin to fizzle out, late in the summer.


Ooookay, so…what else was going on around this fair city, on March 4, 2000? Well, I’m glad you asked. It turns out that Kodo Drummers were playing at Palace Theatre. Also, Tony-winning Broadway performer Audra McDonald is at the nearby Southern Theatre.

The Kenny Road Borders, which is probably my most visited bookstore during this time period, gets into the event based swing of things themselves. They host “Parenting Reading 2000,” an all-day occurrence featuring Pokemon league play for children, a little mini-seminar called Homework: A Parent’s Survival Guide,” a storytelling session with Curious George and Miss Heidi, author Mary Baker Eddy, a sing-along, and crafts. Participants are encouraged to wear pajamas, too.

March 5 ->

Posted on 9 Comments

Riots Of Passage

Front cover image for "Riots Of Passage" by Jason McGathey

Well, like everything else, this book has taken much longer than expected. But Riots Of Passage is finally complete, and now available in both ebook and paperback form. So though it always feels tremendously awkward, I’m forcing myself to insert a little self-promotion here – although considering it documents a year of living on OSU campus, this book counts as legitimate Columbus history, and so might a little bit about its creation, too.

I finally got around to getting this in shape for publication in December 2017. The first draft was finished clear back in the fall of 1998 and the second in the summer of 2003. More than fourteen years would pass, then, before I even looked at this stuff again. Most of the delay was due to working on other projects, but any time I would think about this book, I was having a tough time mentally sorting out the length and the structure.

For eons I’ve been telling everyone that the campus years would be a trilogy (the first installment, One Hundred Virginswas published in 2006). But I could never quite figure out a division point that felt right between two and three, so Riots Of Passage ended up being both. The most natural seeming break occurs after coming home from the New Year’s party, and that was always the plan, except I didn’t like where this meant starting off the last book. It would kind of leave the middle book as one long preamble, as just about all of the payoffs seem to happen in the last half of this finished project.

The major cuts all came with this third draft I began in 2017. That second draft from 2003 clocked in at over 900 full size (8 1/2 x 11″, that is) pages, something like 940, whereas the third one came in at exactly 500. So I wound up cutting out or condensing nearly half of the material. But even throughout this process, I was still kind of stalling on the decision whether to split this into two books or not, telling myself I would know the answer and could make that call when the draft was complete.

But the truth is, you’re never entirely certain you made the right call on anything. In this instance, it felt too short for a pair of books yet too long for just one. It helps considerably with the editing process, though, that I would say – somewhat unexpectedly – that I really don’t care about any of the personal dramas now, stuff which seemed so important at the time. This is one advantage of taking so long to put something together, I suppose. In some instances entire people got the axe, along with subplots which dragged on for a month. The only consideration was whether or not it seemed essential to this central story, and if not, it got the heave ho.

Some of the decisions were pure pacing ones. In the beginning and the end especially, I was going for more of a breezy clip, therefore condensing was unavoidable. This meant that often highly interesting occasions were reduced to single sentences, or maybe even deleted altogether. In two instances I can think of, complete paragraphs which were among my top five favorites, I had to conclude didn’t fit, however painfully, and got rid of them. It sucks, but you can always console yourself with the knowledge that they might find use in other projects down the road.

These decisions, though, make you realize that you can’t really term anything the “definitive” history of an era or a subject. This is just one minuscule slice of history from that time and place. For a while, and this was true of the first book as well, this whole notion of cutting out people completely was bothering me. It feels like you’re trying to alter history based on personal preferences. Except one day I had an epiphany of sorts – I happened to be reading a Civil War book at the time, though it could have been anything – that, you know, they couldn’t possibly mention every single soldier who fought in a war, in the course of the narrative. Attempting to shoehorn in every name even if you have nothing interesting to say would make it clunky and unreadable. This doesn’t make it untrue, or mean that you are attempting to alter history.

One great example of this would occur near the end of this third draft, when I realized that an extremely entertaining cook we worked with at Damon’s hadn’t been mentioned at all. His name just hadn’t come up in any of my writings. Some of his specific episodes I had in my head the whole time, and kept thinking they were going to crop up at some point – after this many years, it’s hard to remember what you included and what you left out of a previous draft – but they never did. Instead of backtracking, though, and attempting to figure out where they belonged, I took this as a sign that these detours probably weren’t needed. And nothing personal against the guy, they just weren’t essential to these particular chapters.

Other times the opposite policy applies, where you figure, you know, I’ve got fifteen scenes at Woody’s in here, or whatever, and these are the ones which felt most crucial. There’s no reason to mention every trip you made to the bar for a solid year. In this sense, some of the lengthier scenes were easier to cut out entirely, or categories where I was able to make some kind of broad editorial decision – so for the most part, major concerts, sporting events, and movies attended were easily gotten rid of. Writing sex scenes, too, has always been awkward, and I couldn’t imagine anyone wanted to read about these icky details either.

So it is that, paradoxically, smaller decisions somehow become the most agonizing. These open up philosophical angles that are often unexpected and fascinating. Though this admission might seem monstrous, I can honestly say that while some of the things I did in these pages should bother me, none of it does. Instead what proves cringe inducing is to look back upon what music you were listening to, the dumb stuff you were talking about, and your inane sense of humor at the time.

Somehow we have all grown accustomed to the notion that our clothing and hair choices of the past were usually questionable, and this we are okay with, dismissing them with wry, morbid humor as a fitting commentary on those hilarious times. Other details prove trickier to navigate, however, and among these I would count a) things you no longer find funny, as well as b) things you no longer believe, and c) things you said, but turned out to not be true.

To leave out these sorts of things, you are then wrestling with the notion that you’re trying to make yourself and your friends seem smoother than you actually were at the time. But I think our various personalities are well established and accurate. Omitting some of the goofier, poorly aged wisecracks or whatever isn’t distorting anything. Also, to include them produces the thought, why would I intentionally write a bad book? Sometimes, particularly with point B up above, you can maybe weave around this by explaining, “here’s what I thought at the time, but I now believe this.” Unless this insight actually occurred during the period in question, though, this is also technically assigning yourself a wisdom you didn’t have.

Thornier still are questions of how you’re going to handle behavior and/or remarks which let’s just say haven’t aged so well, yet they are important if you want to be truthful about these times. You can’t just delete them and pretend they never happened…even though including such makes it seem as though you’re endorsing them. I think you just have to try and keep yourself in the mindset of that time frame as much as possible. It always bugs me when you’re watching something that’s supposedly set in an earlier era, but they’re using slang and catchphrases which didn’t exist back then. I tried to avoid that as much as possible, true, but also more importantly to avoid putting a current spin on these old situations. It’s probably not entirely possible, but I really don’t want to ascribe what I (or anyone else) thinks about these episodes now, only what we actually thought about them back then.

Even so, of course, you end up agonizing over specific words. Some of these sentences remain intact as-is from the late 90s, but there are others, I can tell you, I was still tinkering around with yesterday. Some were bugging me as I went to sleep last night. But at some point you have to tell yourself, good enough. Let it go.

But what really has you in knots most of all, is how you say anything negative whatsoever about your friends. You’re trying to write your interpretation of events, which everyone might not agree with. You don’t want to be unnecessarily mean, but at the same time, if you’re going to excise every negative, then it’s whitewashed and toothless and no longer accurate. It’s easy to fall down additional rabbit holes from there and begin thinking, hey, maybe I’ll just leave in unflattering comments if the person in question was a jerk to me, and on the flipside, delete everything less positive if they were cool. Of course, once you start rationalizing like this, you are doomed. Maybe it’s a tie breaker, if someone is in your good graces, determining how hard you try to paint them favorably, but you cannot just start wiping out every unkind comment about your friends.

Basically I think you just have to ask yourself, is this fair? And is this a necessary reference, or can I cut it out? Have I said this as tactfully as I can manage? It does help that, by this point, hopefully everyone understands this stuff falls in the good natured ribbing department, anyway – as mentioned earlier, I don’t actually “care” about this material on a personal level after this many years, none of it. The only question is if it’s important to this book, this little slice of history I’m covering.

In many of these cases, it’s often an accidental blessing to have not captured a ton of concrete information. Sometimes I am being deliberately vague for dramatic purposes within the structure of the book, other times as some kind of strategic decision I’ve stumbled onto in the real world. But far more common are the instances where I just don’t have the details at this point. You can’t exactly Wikipedia who was at some campus keg party, or what was said at the Out-R-Inn on such and such night from 1998. Work schedules are for the most part toast or would never be made available to you, especially if canned from a place, and you can’t trust memory all that well after this many years.

One thing you may notice is that I do have slightly greater detail as the book progresses. This actually did occur to me at the time, and was an unintended benefit of buying a computer about halfway through this epoch. The whole mindset for acquiring one was that it would help me type up my first novel, yet it would soon turn out that detail and speed in future projects like this were of far greater importance. I was doing an okay job handwriting various facts in my journal, what we did and where we went on such and such day. It helped, too, that I had a job – waiting tables – where standing around scribbling things into a tiny notepad was totally normal. I just often wasn’t writing what they might have expected. But the level of detail is missing beyond this, until able to type it up and capture it quickly with a decent word processing program. And the biggie here is actual quotes, real life soundbites from people, which are somewhat lacking early on.

So if I don’t really care about any of these piddly dramas at this point, beyond their structural purpose in my history, what I do find fascinating now is specific details about anything whatsoever from the distant past. Things said, yes, but also prices, menu items, songs on a band’s set list. Which business existed at a certain address. It does make me lament my focus and choices at times, that I hadn’t concentrated more in certain areas and less in others, but there’s really nothing you can do about that.

Ultimately, this is what a book like this ends up being about: the city itself. Although by the nature of this project forced to insert myself into the middle (fun fact: I did try writing this campus period as a novel with invented character names at one point, many years ago. It didn’t work), it helps considerably to recognize that I am not the story. These experiences on the personal level are for the most part anonymous and commonplace. Though some of this weird behavior I guess is sort of amusing in spots, for the most part, I’m just melting into the background – and that’s exactly as it should be. So while it’s easy for all of us to trick ourselves into thinking, which we probably all have at times, “wow, I’m kinda like the Forrest Gump of this scene or something, all this wild stuff seems to happen when I’m around!” that’s not really how it is at all. It’s more accurate to realize, well, I was present for 100% of the stuff I was present for. That’s why it seems amazing. But there were a million equally crazy things happening all over the place, which I missed. And this swirl of activity, this flood of information and colliding personalities, mixed in with the era and the locale itself, this is really what all such stories are about.

In the end, all you can really control is making a historical record as accurate as possible. Try to make it match what that period felt like as best as you are able to, and move on. The first time around, with One Hundred Virgins, this manifested itself in me thinking I wanted to get the timing right on a typical day. As I was working on that project, it’s true that there were almost no hard decisions whatsoever, as the pacing and flow and questions about which scenes to include almost seemed to be snapping themselves into place, in a way that hasn’t happened before or since with anything I’ve written. But the one area I made a determined effort to focus upon then was to not include only the fireworks, to deliberately insert some boring stretches because this was more realistic. I do regret some of the florid language used in that book – to read some passages now, even I have no clue what I was trying to say there – but otherwise think it accurately captured, you know, that we weren’t partying nonstop, that there were nights I’d sit at the kitchen table alone for hours with the radio and a crossword puzzle.

The period covered in this second volume, however, is completely different. There is much less information about what else is going on around the city, because our lives have gotten more action packed, and I’m also not exactly sitting around reading article after article about Angsto The Clown or whatever, as I had been in our earlier days. Here I think the length of the book is actually more beneficial and accurate, and if I’ve decided to focus less this time around on making every sentence as artfully complex as possible, I do believe that some situational confusion serves it well, because this is how it was to live it. Therefore if you think it’s a bit brain scrambling that there are five or six Carries in this book and most of them have dark hair but no last name, are often explained away as a coworker, well, trust me, this neatly matches our experience. If sometimes you can’t quite decipher what happened or what’s really going on, yeah…welcome to the club.

Even so, I’ve never been nearly this nervous about anything else I’ve written. There are conversations I’ve successfully avoided having for over twenty years now and am dreading to some degree, once a couple of these episodes are revealed. The reception itself otherwise seems almost not nearly as important – as any of you other writers out there know, though you feel compelled to crank this stuff out for some reason, there are always conflicting emotions about it anyway. Am I hoping that nobody reads it? Of course not. Am I hoping that people do read it? I think so…yet it’s still kind of a terrifying prospect to actually sit around and ponder. I mostly try to block out that thought, too.

Original binder for

That last “S” fell off: original cover for “Similar Shapes” as it looks now.

Regarding the title, and the picture above, it’s true that I’ve been wrestling off and on with these names for over two decades. At one point, I intended to call that first book Similar Shapes. There are still times I wish I had. But somewhere along the line that name began to seem too generic to me, and I also became enthralled with this idea, based around this running joke that Robert Smith (from The Cure, not the legendary OSU running back) always had, whenever asked about the title of their next album: he would say One Million Virgins, though they never wound up calling any of them that. When still intending this as a trilogy, I planned to run with that concept in tying them all together, starting with Hundred and then Thousand, finally Million. 

Though loosely based upon discussions we were actually having at the time, this numbering pattern eventually lost its luster. True, I could always pull an Agatha Christie and rename that first book. But really, I think I’m saving Similar Shapes for a day down the road, when I might decide to combine these two projects and issue them as one. Half the time I think that will probably happen at some point. It actually makes the most sense of all, and kind of comes full circle to that maroon binder full of pages.

Anyway, if you’re really worked up into a mad fervor and can’t wait to get your claws into a copy, as I mentioned, the Kindle version is on promotion now on Amazon. So here is the link for that:

Riots Of Passage 

And the paperback version is now available too! I would recommend the Barnes and Noble version most of all. It’s $6 cheaper than Amazon’s paperback, yet of much higher quality. Amazon busts your chops about making sure every file is just so, then it comes out kind of blurry and misaligned anyway. So here’s the link to the B&N paperback:

Riots Of Passage paperback

Other options abound, too, though I won’t clutter up the page posting every link here. Suffice to say it’s available wherever you would expect. My favorite though is Smashwords, a nifty little author-friendly operation that gives you multiple options for downloading:

Riots Of Passage on Smashwords

By the way, if you’re interested in reviewing this book, I can definitely be persuaded to send you a free copy in pretty much any form. Either leave a comment below, or email me (jasonmcgatheywriter@gmail.com), or else you can always send a message/text/call me, et cetera of course if we happen to be friends already.

Let me know if you spot any errors, of course. I already have a file going with a couple of them, though at this point I guess they will have to wait for the inevitable revised edition. As always, thanks for reading this or anything else that pops into my head. It still seems amazing to me that anyone would do so, and I hope to never lose sight of that.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted on 3 Comments

Buckeye Hall Of Fame Cafe

Burgers page on Buckeye Hall Of Fame Cafe menu.

Originally, ownership of the Damon’s on Olentangy planned to open a brand new building for that same chain, right across the parking lot. I know because I happened to be working there at the time. Instead, plans were soon scrapped in favor of a separate plot of land, a different operation entirely. This would have been 1997. Management was threatening us all with this incessant best of the best nonsense, insisting they would only accept top shelf talent for a transfer to the new restaurant. The hilarious conclusion to this tale is that only two employees bothered signing up anyway – our daytime manager Drew, and some part time prep cook. The best of the best? I’m not sure management quite filled their stated objective, there. If this is a Hall Of Fame cafe, its inaugural class doesn’t exactly rival Cooperstown’s.

The Buckeye Hall of Fame Café, they’re terming this latest venture. Great, just what campus needs. Nonetheless, when a Columbus institution, the Jai Lai, shutters its doors (at 1421 Olentangy River Road) in August of ’96, the brain trust behind our Damon’s decides to swoop in for the kill. Jai Lai was Woody Hayes’s favorite restaurant in town, and his efforts alone generated all sorts of revenue for the place. Still, local fervor for this niche notwithstanding, I get the feeling it will take a lot more than the support of an OSU football coach to keep this latest venture afloat. Plus, well, let’s not forget that Woody Hayes died in 1987.

A couple miles south of the Damon’s, also on Olentangy, past the brand new baseball field and the Jack Nicklaus museum, past the Lennox spaceship shopping center, directly facing the river, this building they do cobble together with impressive, land speed record time, I’ll give them that. Still, Buckeye football fans are already the most annoying aficionados on the planet, and this added fuel surely won’t help matters any. And while there are surely token efforts at championing the other sports under this umbrella, we all know what the driving force is behind this venture.

The football team used to hold weekly press conferences here, after all, back when it was the Jai Lai, and they even experimented with helicoptering patrons from here to the game back in ’74. So yes, a cursed shrine to OSU heroes of yore, as if these nuts don’t already vomit scarlet and grey factoids three hundred sixty five days a year. For what, a season that lasts all of eleven games. Every spring, the Buckeyes play an exhibition football game, serving no real purpose, except these too are always inexhaustibly attended by another capacity mob. You could probably plant an OSU flag in a dog turd and folks would pay to see it. Then again, some might argue this is exactly what happened during the John Cooper years.

As for us employees, the whole experience leaves a sour taste in our mouths – at least to the extent you could claim we care. Thus our avoidance falls somewhere between a boycott and pure lack of interest. For one, despite the threats, bigwigs like John Votino telling us we needed to get our act together or we weren’t going to be brought on board the “new Damon’s” they were allegedly building “right across the parking lot” from our current location, the timeline just isn’t adding up. He’s barking this junk at us in a late January meeting, about an alleged March groundbreaking…but then two weeks later the same team is in the news announcing that they’re opening this Buckeye Café. No mention of this new Damon’s location is ever made again. All of which can only mean one of three things:  

a) he was purposefully blowing smoke up our asses as some kind of weird motivational stunt, fully aware that there was no new Damon’s being built in our parking lot, that they were buying a shuttered restaurant miles away from here, and revamping it.  

b) they somehow decided in the space of two weeks and then made this purchase happen, along with the entire name and marketing angle they presented to the Dispatch.

c) my own personal theory, that he isn’t quite the bigwig nor as in the loop as he thinks he is and that the guys above him in the food chain – i.e. the fat cats with the money, making the actual, you know, decisions – had scrapped that “new Damon’s” business months upon months earlier, and he was relating to us old, outdated news.

But in the name of journalistic curiosity, if nothing else, I owe it to myself to inspect this place at least once, and it seems that the rest of our gang feels the same way.  

So after months of hearing Buckeye Café this, Hall Of Fame Café that, is this adding up to the eighth wonder of western civilization? Well, not quite. But as we pull up before this bright, two story oasis, glowing red as a fireplace ember, they do offer valet parking, a perk at least as good as Jon Axelrod’s suggestion that our own restaurant give out umbrellas when it’s raining. We don’t find the need to pay them for this service, though, for while the second floor of this building, in a clever twist, actually is a parking garage, there are also plenty of spots available here at street level, off to the side.  

The building exterior, though modern enough, is a concrete bunker painted grey, vaguely reminiscent of a castle, with scarlet flags billowing from strategic points up top. They’ve even gone as far as to sculpt roadside hedges low, in the familiar O shape of that famous Buckeye logo.  Once inside, we find a number of different bars scattered throughout the grounds, and the atmosphere is warm, inviting. The expected OSU memorabilia and color schemes dominate every available square inch, with the patron level, while not jam packed, certainly higher than you might expect an hour before closing time on a Tuesday in January. Everything is well lit and looks tastefully modern.  

Still, having already decided I’m not going to spend any money here personally, and with my roommate Damon also in more of a fact finding mode, our visit here is not bound to represent an extensive, in depth one. There’s an adequate dining area, a roomy pool hall, and an even roomier game room, which is where we find Jenny, Carrie, and John. We watch them manipulate joysticks, race digital vehicles, and fire off basketballs in the face of a shot clock and scoreboard continually broadcasting their ineptitude. Soon enough, the hour dictates that those responsible are closing this place down for the night, and we leave just a little bit shy of this development.

A glance at the menu lends the impression that this is standard sports bar food, nothing more. Still, given the theme of this place, you would have expected more imagination in at least the naming of the dishes. It would seem a no-brainer to honor famous Buckeye personalities with signature meals and drinks, possibly even crafting some menu items that were known favorites for these legends. What was Woody Hayes’s idea of a perfect food, for example, and why wouldn’t you have that on offer here? Or Archie Griffin’s or Jesse Owens’s? They seem to have dropped the ball on the two yard line with this one.

On an amusing side note, they once paid $10,000 to set an OSU Buckeye logo in the concrete directly before the front entrance. Except one afternoon it mysteriously acquired bike tire tracks before the wet concrete had dried. Yeah, that was me. Even so, I doubt this really impacted much, as they were able to stay in business for many a year after this, before finally going belly up in 2009. 

Somewhere around 2011, this concept and presumably much of its memorabilia was transferred to a new restaurant, at the Port Columbus International Airport. It has the same name and logo, so I would assume the same brain trust is behind this operation. This too seems to have gone bust, though in half the time as the previous incarnation – about six years, give or take – and the Yelp! rating may help explain why. Reviews are fairly brutal, especially in later years, and they wound up with a composite 2 star score.

 

Posted on Leave a comment

Ohio State Pizza

A pie is on the way, I’m told, from Ohio State Pizza, which has emerged after all these months as my and Alan’s clear cut favorite. Damon doesn’t much care, because nine times out of ten he’s only interested in the crust. We consider him crazy, but many a night Alan and I will come home, or awaken, to find an entire pizza crammed into our fridge, with the exception that its entire outlying crust is gone. Damon always instructs us to eat the rest if confronted with this, that he never will. And so by process of elimination, and discarding my lone Gumby’s experience, which, aside from an easily recalled phone number (29GUMBY) and their virtual around the clock delivery policy, has little to recommend itself, Ohio State Pizza receives this couch cushion change jangling so loudly in our pockets.

At the northeastern cusp of campus housing, the corner of Hudson and Indianola, Ohio State Pizza functions in an unassuming bandbox about as big as a can of tomato paste. Family owned, family managed, enabling the modest perks and quirks that set it apart. The driver always shows up wearing no shirt, no shoes, jeans slung low enough around the waist to broadcast a good three inches of his tighty whitey underwear. So out of step, our first few times ordering from these cats we assume it’s the same dude showing up, but then we notice that all the drivers have adopted this curious dress code, leading us to rename the establishment Redneck Pizza in their honor. On exactly one occasion we swing through for pick up, but after watching the admittedly mind boggling swift crew dance around one another on autopilot as they throw every food safety precaution aside without a thought, it occurs to us that the inner workings of some machines are best left to the imagination. And anyway, though these wheels are certainly mighty tasty, the main thrust of our infatuation had been from day one that they deliver beer and cigarettes, too, and that no matter how many young girls cavort around inside your apartment as you call, in the background as you accept and pay they never, under any circumstances, ask for ID.

Always, the delivery man’s interruption. The contemporary shirtless low-riding jeans specimen from Ohio State Pizza slams on the brakes curbside and hurdles across the lawn, appeasing our laziness with another extra large oven offering. Sliced in the old fashioned spoke style few companies fool with anymore, another bonus. Having already narrowed down our preferred establishments to two, some insider Gumby’s information Jeremy passed along the other night, gleaned from a mutual friend of ours named Steve who works there, officially knocks them from contention as well. Roaches the size of pepperoni, he says.

We did make the mistake once of drifting inside Ohio State Pizza for a pickup order. This is an experience I wouldn’t necessarily recommend. As you might gather from the photo above, confines are cramped in there, leaving little breathing room as you stand around and wait. Plus something about seeing these pie crafting wizards in action ruined the magic a little bit. Well, it’s either that, or maybe that which is hilarious when brought to your house isn’t quite so if viewed at the source. I’m sure it’s perfectly sanitary and all – and this place remains in operation, to this day, which bespeaks quality – but let’s just say the low-riding jeans, shirtless delivery aesthetic remains in place at home base. Some things are meant to be inferred but not seen.